Thursday, March 10, 2011

The Question of Quality: Education Faces Budget Cuts

The audience sits silently in a pool of darkness waiting on the edge of their seats for the first movement. I sit backstage with baby butterflies in my stomach and a pound of make up on my face. Although I was alone in this moment, I was confident that as soon as I stepped on stage all of my hours of reciting lines, finding emotional connection to my character and hard work would pay off. The amount of pride I had in this moment was a powerful feeling, one that is simply indescribable. This will be the last time I look up at the blinding spot lights from the stage of my high school. With the exception of the necessary knowledge I needed in order to graduate from high school, my life was shaped on this stage. Within the hours of rehearsal, came the unbreakable bond between my cast members and I, I learned how to work in a team and be a leader to those who needed one. I learned how inspire audiences with my confidence and capture an entire room.Our theatre program was the best in the state, one of the top in the nation and highly respected by almost everyone. No, I did not go to a private school with money being thrown at our theatre program. In order to fund our program, we took the money the district gave us, had a huge auction every year and recruited enthusiastic parents to be in a booster club. In order to be in the school musical, on top of exhausting auditions and demanding rehearsals, every student was required to raise $300. Drama was the most important part of my public education and if it wasn’t for the outside help we received for funding, none of it would have happened and I would have been lacking something in my education and in myself as a whole. The things I learned being involved in an arts program are the most valuable lessons I learned in high school, and I was never even in a classroom when learning them.
Moments and learning opportunities like these are at risk because of budget cuts. When schools are forced to get rid of programs, arts programs are the first to go. If I was in a position of power in a state or national government, one of my top priorities would be the quality of the public school system. As someone who attended public school, I have seen all the ways state budget can affect a school. With the recent economic downturn, everyone has been tightening their belts on spending. More people have been choosing to enroll their children in public schools instead of spending thousands of dollars on a private education. As a result, public schools are becoming overcrowded and resources are dwindling. On top of students having to use out of date books and sitting on old chairs, they are also stuck in classes of forty students with one underpaid teacher. Now, the Colorado government is starting to talk about more budget cuts within the state. Because of this, funding will be cut from public education. Denver Post writer Ivan Moreno describes the budget cuts, saying “Colorado faces a budget shortfall near $1 billion for the fiscal year that starts in July. Hickenlooper's suggested budget could prompt teacher layoffs and bigger class sizes in many districts.” (Moreno, Denver Post) The government helps fund thousands of things in the state, things that are much less important than the education of citizens. We have to find alternative revenue so the quality of education in Colorado does not dissolve into nothing.
Education is one of the most precious gifts in the entire world. The value of knowledge can enable one to expand their horizons and invigorate them to move forward and change the world. With recent budget cuts within the government in Colorado, the public education system is being given less money to keep the programs funded. With these cuts, the quality of education is going down and classes are getting bigger. Students are not able to work to their full potential with circumstances such as these and are unable to thrive as they should. When such a large thing is being put at risk, there is little room for opportunity because either way something will have to be sacrificed. The government has to analyze the type of impact these budget cuts will have on the school system and decide if education is really the right area to take money out of. Education at the national level had also experienced lack of funding for the arts, an area that positively affected my education more than I can even put into words. Now, the cuts reach beyond the arts, now impacting teachers jobs which will negatively affect the state because “Layoffs and other job losses lower consumer spending, which powers 70 percent of the economy.” (Associated Press, Denver Post) If the people are not being encouraged to work to their full potential, the state will slowly fall apart and the economy could suffer if people don’t have the skills to keep it working. Although wealthy people might not feel the impact as much because they have the ability to keep their children enrolled in private schools, those who don’t have that opportunity will see an unfortunate chain of events as their children eventually end up in the same economic situation as their parents were.  
These budget cuts will not only affect the students, but teachers will also be at risk of losing their jobs. Almost everyone has a reason to be concerned. Parents should be worried about the education their children are receiving, teachers should be concerned about their jobs, students should be worried about their futures being at risk because of a lack of knowledge and the government should be worried about their education sysrem falling apart completely. Although it might be understandable why the government thinks that education is a reasonable area to make cuts in, they definitely have to think about the long term sacrifices they will be making in order to keep spending down. Is education really the place they should be making cuts? With questions such as this looming in the air, it has become time for the citizens of Colorado to make choices about where they are willing to put their money. If these cuts are actually made, Colorado citizens may have to start paying higher taxes to ensure the quality of education.
With the proposed cuts, there would be “a $332 million net reduction over funding for K-12 in the current year, or $497 less per kid.” (Hoover, Denver Post) This isn’t pocket change we’re talking about here. Without those $497 dollars per student, we lose books, quality cafeteria food, technology and dozens of other things we don’t even know are there. We were already struggling with old books, slow computers and a general lack of resources at my school, and I can imagine Colorado schools are dealing with the same issues. Cutting the funding even more will lead Colorado schools into a never ending cycle of teachers being fired, students dropping out because they’re unmotivated and the economy will spiral downhill. The amount of money Hickenlooper is proposing to cut is too much. Students cannot afford to have art programs, music programs and athletic programs taken away from their schools. These are the things that keep students focused, ambitious and involved. Without them, education lacks wholeness and does not shape the student in all the aspects that it should. No class teaches how to work in a team or how to motivate others, these things are learned in passing, simply by taking advantage of programs schools should have to offer.
In order to make a reasonable decision about this issue, the citizens and the government have to evaluate the choices we have and also decide what our definition of quality in terms of education is. Does a quality education mean old books, big classes, slow computers and a diploma at the end of four years with no real knowledge to back it up? Or does it mean updated books, attention from teachers, useful technology and an acceptance to a good college? We have to define quality and shape the ideal education before we start resisting budget cuts. One of the problems is that students might not realize how important their education really is and might not be as enthusiastic about making sure their school does not get significantly impacted by these cuts. Students might not care that they aren’t getting personal attention from their teachers because it enables them to get away with not doing homework and cheating on exams. In reality, these students are only hurting themselves by not putting in their best work. We need the help of parents and teachers alike to encourage students to take advantage of the resources they have and also inspire them to gain knowledge from outside resources other than school. 

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Cut It Or Shut It

Currently, the U.S. economy is struggling, this is nothing new or surprising, but it is happening and it is real. While it is on the uprising, it is still weak and people are working harder than ever to make it work. Everyone is struggling, especially when cuts are being made left and right from state and local funding. Perhaps one of the most heavily effected areas in the state of Colorado is education. Already on a tight budget, more cuts to public education means larger classes, less schools, and cut backs in all areas. With so much of the states budget allocated to education, it is the most difficult area to cut funds because it affects the most people. In a country where education is already weak enough, the state is going to try and make it work, just on less money. This doesn’t just mean less money for those in K-12, but also for higher education such as University of Colorado Boulder. Nobody wants to take money from children, especially children who need it most, those in public education. However, money is tight, and unless cuts are made, or taxes are increased, education is going to take a big hit.
The reason so many discussions on cutting education funding have come up, is because of the recent budget released by Governor Hickenlooper. Cuts exceed over 550 million to the overall budget, 332 million towards public education alone. This includes all levels of schooling, K-12 and public colleges. Cuts as drastic as this are not to be taken lightly, but Hickenlooper feels it is in the best interest of the state to cut back on certain areas, one of those being education. Nobody should be proud or impressed by the size of the cuts, its nothing to be taken lightly. The Governor has been quoted as saying "There's nothing I've ever grappled with as long and hard as that," said of the cuts to K-12 schools. "My son is in public school.” While he is cutting from the budget of education, it is not to say Mr. Hickenlooper doesn’t care about it, he is simply looking at the long-term side of things. If we can save money now, when times are most difficult, once we climb out of this recession, the schools will be stronger than ever. Yes, the cuts are drastic, but in order to maintain order in the state, something radical must be done. If these cuts are made, then the students will feel the affects, but not nearly as hard as the teachers. Teacher’s salaries make up 65 percent of the allotted education funding which alone is 40 percent of the total budget. With a state budget of 1.1 billion dollars, nearly 4.5 million dollars is spent on public education.
Bill Gates, one the richest men in the world along with being one of the largest donors towards education, has a lot to say on this issue. He firmly believes that closing schools and raising class size is not the best option. However he doesn’t entirely disagree with increasing class sizes. In his mind, schools should find the best teachers, not necessarily those who have been there longest, and give them more students and more money. This not only rewards the best teachers, but also provides incentive for other teachers to work higher. The idea that they need motivation to teach better is an issue all on its own. Teachers work for a certain number of years and reach a status or tenure. At this point they are safe from being fired, and continue to collect a paycheck as long as they keep coming to class. Not the best group to be teaching the minds of tomorrow. Gates would like to see more money, a lot of which he donates, go towards researching new technologies for students to better help them learn. Also, he thinks that teachers need to be paid on degrees, not length of stay.
There are many ways to save money in a struggling economy, make budget cuts, or raise taxes. Nobody is a fan of either because it means less money in their pockets. So which is a more efficient way to raise money, and or cut down on certain things? Each has their own drawbacks, but everyone is affected by taxes, and only certain groups hurt from cutting certain programs. For example if you raise taxes which everyone pays, then it influences more people than cutting funding to a state park which not everyone may visit. There really is no fair way to do it than to raise various taxes such as alcohol or gas, or all taxes like state and sales. Raising taxes is a risky operation, but without it people will have to deal with cuts and less spending. Senators, Governors, and any political office take huge risks in raising taxes because it can ruin their political career and potential reelection. But, this is not a popularity contest, well maybe it is, but they need to do what is best for the people who elected them there in the first place.
There really is no other way around it, by raising taxes, government officials can save the public education system, and at the least make less cuts that affect the children. While raising taxes takes money from citizens, it also benefits them in numerous ways. Without raising taxes schools suffer. Whenever a school shuts down class sizes increases at other schools making for a less conducive environment. Teachers have to deal with more students, less materials, and difficult teaching environments. They key to fixing education in America is not closing schools and cutting programs, but that is what everyone seems to be doing. This year in Texas alone, there will be 10 billion dollars less to spend on education. In Colorado we are trying to save money by cutting after school programs, and shortening the school year. Clearly it could be a lot worse, like those in the Lone Star State. Some states have gone so far as to cut all funding for full day Kindergarten programs.
There is no magic pill that will fix the economy, or no equation to make more money. The only way that Colorado can continue to survive economically is if men like Governor Hickenlooper step up to the plate and make some cuts. This is easier said then done considering that the cuts he has proposed involve cutting huge chucks of money from the public school system. This affects all aspects of schools ranging from kindergarten to college. The proposed budget cut affects teacher’s salaries, creates job losses, and even hurts those who live near schools, but it really puts innocent students in vulnerable positions. According to President Obama education is one of, if not the most important aspects of our future. Yet, in Colorado the Governor is making the largest budget cuts to public education in history. Everyone wants to pay less taxes and cut funding to certain areas, but when asked what to cut the funding to, nobody wants to do anything. The Governor is simply doing what he feels is best for the people of Colorado, because after all we did elect him.



http://www.denverpost.com/search/ci_17502124
http://www.denverpost.com/search/ci_17476619
http://www.denverpost.com/ci_17483674?IADID=Search-www.denverpost.com-www.denverpost.com
http://www.denverpost.com/legislature/ci_17396904?IADID=Search-www.denverpost.com-www.denverpost.com
http://www.denverpost.com/legislature/ci_17434330?IADID=Search-www.denverpost.com-www.denverpost.com
http://www.denverpost.com/opinion/ci_17417701?IADID=Search-www.denverpost.com-www.denverpost.com

Thursday, March 3, 2011

To Cut or Not to Cut: State Budget vs. Education

On the morning of February 15th, Gov. John Hickenlooper made the difficult decision to make extreme budget cuts within the education system in an effort to fix the deeply struggling economy. This final decision made by Hickenlooper has obviously created a great deal of conflict and discussion among the people who currently reside in Colorado. As a new resident of Colorado and a recent student at the University of Denver, I have personally witnessed first-hand the reaction that this bill has had towards the people of this state. It comes to no surprise that the residents here, especially those who have or will have children in the public school system, are furious with Hickenlooper’s decision. These budget cuts will affect many aspects of the school system extending from elementary grades to college level such as CU Boulder and CSU.

The main reason that Hickenlooper had to make this decision was to compensate for a $1.1 billion shortfall in the state budget. This shortfall has been building gradually and is mainly due to the recession; stimulus money from our nation’s government is running out and one-time fixes are not cutting it any longer. The budget cut in education is not the only area that will receive attention from Hickenlooper, however it is one of the greatest affecting areas to the people of Colorado. The total cut for education will be around $332 million. There will have to be an increase in class sizes within all levels of education due to teachers being laid off, as well as an increase in in-state tuition, and a decrease in the quality of the education that students will ultimately receive. This is mainly because higher education makes up forty percent of the state budget. Hickenlooper acknowledges the upset that this proposed budget plan has created. However his reasoning behind the cuts in education specifically have to do with the fact that he absolutely did not want to raise taxes and potentially upset the people. He stated, “There is still a deep-seated belief out there that in this economy, people don’t want to pay more taxes.” In an article written by Tim Hoover in the Denver Post, Hoover quotes Hickenlooper as saying, “‘There’s nothing I’ve ever grappled with as long and hard as that,’ Hickenlooper said of the cut to K-12 schools, ‘My son is in public school.’” Obviously this decision on the governor’s part was not an easy one to make in any respect.

Another reason for the large amount of budget cuts was the fact that Hickenlooper wanted to keep a safety net for the state. In his proposed budget plan, he insisted that we keep a larger amount of money in the state’s general fund in reserve. Although others proposed that we should lower it to 2 percent in reserve, Hickenlooper was adamant that the level should be kept at 4 percent in reserve. In a recent Denver Post article by Tim Hoover, Hickenlooper was quoted as saying, “I just don't believe you can operate without some sort of cushion. It's reasonable.” However, keeping 4 percent of the state’s budget in reserve means that an additional $141.5 million would need to be cut from the budget. This is yet another reason why the budget cuts were so extreme in education.

These major cuts in education will affect schooling at all levels. Teacher layoffs and an increase in class sizes are only the beginning. Parents want their children to get the best education possible. By sending their children to the public schools in Colorado, that is what they expect that they will receive. However, when class sizes begin to increase, especially in grades K-12, the productivity and success rates of students are extremely affected. Students need individual attention especially through these grade levels. This is the time in our lives when we are shaped into students and when we build up our work ethic. When class sizes begin to increase and there is less one-on-one student-teacher interaction, it is much easier for a student to fall behind and potentially ruin their overall motivation for years to come. More specifically, we are able to see some of the possible outcomes for the lower education in Colorado based upon the effect that education cuts have had in other states recently. Tim Hoover’s article in the Denver Post, “Colorado’s Education Cuts Mirror Situation Across U.S.” reflects upon the outcomes of a couple other areas of the nation. For example, there were budget cuts to K-12 education last year in Arizona that resulted in completely eliminating state-funding for a full day of kindergarten as well as reduced money for textbooks, technology, and other teaching tools. A similar situation occurred in North Carolina where budget cuts forced a one-year moratorium on replacing school buses. These are only a couple examples of the potential consequences resulting from the current budget cuts in Colorado.

Although I attend a private university instead of a large state school, the impact that these budget cuts have on the state will be apparent to any person living in Colorado. The budget cuts will affect elementary school, junior high, and high schools. However, the cuts will be most apparent in the higher education system of our state. I’ve visited CU Boulder a couple times; one of my cousins and a couple of good friends are students there. They tell me that class sizes are on average pretty large due to the fact that it is a public state school. They say that they walk in to their classes and if it’s not a lecture there are normally around 18 to 25 other students in attendance. This class size is pretty manageable; there is opportunity to get to know the professor, actively participate, discuss, as well as meet other students. Now, imagine walking into a classroom in which you expect to be able to do these things previously stated, but are now surrounded by about 30 to 40 students. This is an unmanageable amount that can prevent even the brightest of students from taking full advantage of the class. In classrooms that aren’t lectures, discussion is usually the most important aspect of learning. It stimulates students to think, gets them involved, and allows them to interact with other students and intellectuals. If a student enrolls in a class that should have around 20 students, but has increased to 30 due to budget cuts, this will deeply affect the experience and overall quality of the class they attend. These students and parents that pay good money to go to a university and acquire a college education should receive the education that they pay for. By making these budget cuts and increasing class sizes and probably tuition as well, the quality of higher education in Colorado will eventuallly decrease.

Overall, the budget cuts in education that Hickenlooper has decided to make are extremely controversial. They will ultimately help to fix the $1.1 billion shortfall in the state’s budget, but at what cost? We, as residents and students in Colorado need to decide if Hickenlooper’s proposed plan is worth the amount that it will ultimately have on the lower education and higher education throughout our state.